The Advocate General Delivers his Opinion in Case C-470/21 | La Quadrature du Net and Others

 

<<Advocate General Szpunar: the retention of, and access to, civil identity data linked to the IP address used should be allowed in cases where those data are the only means of investigation that make it possible to identify the perpetrators of copyright infringements committed exclusively on the internet.>>

 

According to Press Release No. 151/23 of September 27, 2023, the Advocate General delivered his Opinion (“Opinion”) in Case C-470/21 | La Quadrature du Net and Others. This Opinion is submitted in the context of the resumption of the proceedings in this case (“Case”).

In his Opinion, First Advocate General Szpunar takes the view that EU law does not require providers of electronic communications services to store IP addresses and related civil identification data and does not prevent an administrative authority responsible for protecting copyrights against infringements committed on the internet from accessing such addresses and data.

The Hadopi (High Authority for the dissemination of works and the protection of rights online) subject to the Opinion is as follows;

  • When copyright infringement by an internet user is detected, Hadopi will issue an advisory to the user requesting that they refrain from further infringement, followed by a new warning in the event of repeat infringement. If the first two warnings are ignored and a third infringement occurs, Hadopi may refer the matter to the competent judicial authority for criminal proceedings.
  • The Conseil d'État (Council of State, France) asks the Court of Justice whether the collection of civil identification data corresponding to IP addresses and the automatic processing of this data for the purpose of preventing infringement of intellectual property rights without prior review by a court or an independent administrative body is compatible with EU law.

Opinion on this issue includes the following;

  • The Advocate General considers that the IP address, the civilian identity of the person who has the right to access the internet, and information about the work in question do not make it possible to draw firm conclusions about the private life of the alleged copyright infringer.
  • This measure is intended to allow the authority in question to identify the owners of addresses suspected of committing infringements and, where appropriate, to take action against them.
  •  This data is the only investigative tool that makes it possible to identify the person to whom the address in question was assigned at the time of the infringement.

The Advocate General makes it clear that this is not a departure from existing case-law, but a pragmatic development of that case law, making it possible to reach a nuanced solution in specific and very narrowly defined circumstances. According to the Advocate General, this analysis is the result of balancing the various interests involved.

You can access the press release here.

You can access the full text of the Opinion here.

Kind regards,

Zumbul Attorneys-at-Law

info@zumbul.av.tr