According to Advocate General Medina, the Mandatory Collection and Storage of Fingerprints in Identity Cards is Valid

According to the Advocate General’s Opinion in Case C-61/22, Regulation 2019/1157[1] sets out the obligation to include, as of 2 August 2021, on a highly secure storage medium, an image of the fingerprints of the holder in any identity card newly issued by the Member States.

In November 2021, a German citizen applied for a new identity card from the City of Wiesbaden in Germany. The citizen specifically requested that the card be issued without including a fingerprint image on its chip. However, the City of Wiesbaden rejected the application, stating that it was mandatory to store a fingerprint image in the chip of new identity cards since August 2, 2021.

The Administrative Court of Wiesbaden has expressed doubts about the validity of Regulation 2019/1157 and the mandatory requirement of collecting and storing fingerprints in German identity cards. Specifically, the court seeks clarification on whether the appropriate legal basis for adopting the regulation was Article 21(2) of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union (“TFEU”) rather than Article 77(3) of the same treaty. Additionally, the court questions the compatibility of Regulation 2019/1157 with Articles 7 and 8 of the Charter of Fundamental Rights, read in conjunction with Article 52(1) of the Charter. Furthermore, the court raises concerns about whether the regulation complies with the obligation to conduct a data protection impact assessment as required by Article 35(10) of the General Data Protection Regulation (“GDPR”)[2].

Advocate General Laila Medina concludes that Regulation 2019/1157 was properly adopted under Article 21(2) of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union (TFEU), aiming to facilitate the exercise of the right of EU citizens to move and reside freely within the Member States. She highlights that this right allows EU citizens to fully integrate into the daily life of the host Member State. National identity cards serve the same purpose for both EU citizens and residents, providing reliable and authentic proof of identity, which is essential for the unrestricted enjoyment of free movement.

The standardization and enhanced reliability of national identity cards, including the inclusion of digital fingerprints, directly benefit the exercise of the right to free movement by making these cards more trustworthy and widely accepted by authorities and service providers. This ultimately reduces inconvenience, costs, and administrative barriers for mobile EU citizens. Advocate General Laila Medina concludes that the competence granted to the Council under Article 77(3) of the Treaty on TFEU should be understood as limited to border check policy. Therefore, Regulation 2019/1157, which extends beyond this scope, would not fall within the ambit of that provision.

Regarding the question of whether the limitations imposed by Regulation 2019/1157 serve a legitimate general interest, Advocate General Laila Medina believes that the lack of uniformity in formats and security features of national identity cards increases the risk of falsification and document fraud. Therefore, the limitations introduced by Regulation 2019/1157, which aim to prevent such risks and promote the acceptance of these cards, serve the objective of enhancing security and combating fraud.

Additionally, Advocate General Laila Medina concludes that the limitations imposed by Regulation 2019/1157 are appropriate, and necessary, and do not exceed what is essential to achieve the main objective of the regulation. She believes that there is no equally suitable but less intrusive method compared to the collection and storage of fingerprints for effectively achieving the regulation's aim. Furthermore, the regulation includes adequate measures to protect the collection, storage, and use of biometric identifiers from misuse and abuse. These measures ensure that the biometric identifiers stored in the issued card are solely accessible to the cardholder and not publicly available. The regulation does not establish the creation or maintenance of national or centralized databases at the EU level. Regarding the requirement of a data protection impact assessment under Article 35(10) of the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR), the Advocate General highlights that the GDPR and Regulation 2019/1157 hold equal status as secondary legislation in the hierarchy of EU law. She asserts that the GDPR does not impose an obligation on the EU legislature to conduct an impact assessment during the legislative process for adopting Regulation 2019/1157.

You can access the full text of the press release here.

 

Kind regards,

Zumbul Attorneys-at-Law

info@zumbul.av.tr

 


[1] Article 3(5) of Regulation 2019/1157 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 20 June 2019 on strengthening the security of identity cards of Union citizens and of residence documents issued to Union citizens and their family members exercising their right of free movement (OJ 2019 L 188, p. 67)

[2] Article 35(10) of Regulation (EU) 2016/679 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 27 April 2016 on the protection of natural persons with regard to the processing of personal data and on the free movement of such data, and repealing Directive 95/46/EC (General Data Protection Regulation) (OJ 2016 L 119, p. 1)