Evaluation of the Guidelines for the Transfer of Personal Data Abroad

The Guideline on the Transfer of Personal Data Abroad ("Guideline") published by the Data Protection Authority ("Authority") has been prepared to guide the implementation of the amendments made to Article 9 titled "Transfer of Personal Data Abroad" of the Data Protection Law No. 6698 ("Law") with Article 34 of Law No. 7499 on Amendments to the Criminal Procedure Law and Certain Laws, published in the Official Gazette dated 12.03.2024 and numbered 32487.

The Guideline answers the following questions;

  • What are the methods stipulated in the legislation for transferring personal data abroad?
  1. What is an adequacy decision and how can it be issued?
  2. Within the scope of transfer based on appropriate safeguards:
  • What does providing appropriate safeguards through an agreement that is not an international contract entail?
  • What are binding corporate rules, and how do they provide appropriate safeguards?
  • What are standard contract clauses, and how do they ensure appropriate safeguards?
  • What is the provision of appropriate safeguards through a commitment?
  1. What are the methods for transferring personal data abroad under the scope of exceptional transfer?
  2. Who will be responsible for the transfer of personal data abroad?

How was the Process of Transferring Personal Data Abroad Conducted before the Amendments to the Law?

Before the amendment of the Law, there were two methods for transferring personal data abroad. These are;

1. Based on explicit consent or

2. Transfer through commitment.

When the implementation of the Law was analysed, it was possible to transfer personal data from Turkey to foreign countries, except for obtaining the explicit consent of the data subjects, upon the written commitment of the data controllers in our country and in the relevant country to provide adequate protection and the permission of the Data Protection Board (“Board”). Until 1.06.2024, 86 commitment applications were made to the Board and only 10 of them were accepted by the Board.

As can be seen, these methods made it very difficult to use cloud-based software and applications, most of which are used in commercial life and whose servers are located abroad, in accordance with the law.

For the reasons explained, the Law has been amended based on the European Union General Data Protection Regulation No. 2016/679 (“General Data Protection Regulation”), which entered into force on 28.05.2018.

Which Situations will be Considered as Transfer of Personal Data Abroad?

Sending/transferring personal data from our country to a party abroad does not necessarily constitute a transfer of personal data abroad. If the following 3 conditions are fulfilled, it will be accepted that the transfer of personal data abroad has taken place:

  • The transferred party must be located in a foreign country.
  • The transfer must have been made between parties other than the data subject.
  • Personal data must have been transmitted or made accessible to the foreign country.

If all of these criteria are fulfilled, Article 9 of the Law must be complied with. In the Guidelines, situations that constitute data transfer abroad and those that do not constitute data transfer abroad are clarified with the following examples.

 

What is the Roadmap to be Followed in the Transfer of Personal Data Abroad?

 

  1. In order to transfer personal data abroad, it must first be examined whether one of the personal data processing conditions specified in Articles 5 and 6 of the Law is fulfilled. This examination is sought as a “Prerequisite” for data transfer abroad.
  2. If one of the conditions for processing personal data required by the Law is fulfilled, the existence of an ‘Adequacy Decision’ is examined. If there is an Adequacy Decision, transfer abroad can be made.
  3. If there is no Adequacy Decision and the conditions for processing personal data are also fulfilled, the existence of ‘Appropriate Safeguards’ is examined. If there are appropriate safeguards, transfer abroad can be made.
  4. In the absence of an Adequacy Decision and appropriate safeguards, transfers may be made abroad if there are exceptional transfer conditions without any prerequisites.

Stage 1: What is an adequacy decision and how can it be issued?

In order for personal data to be transferred abroad, the fulfilment of one of the conditions for processing personal data and special categories of personal data specified in the Law is required as a prerequisite.

An “Adequacy Decision” issued by the Authority stating that the country, an international organisation or a specific sector within this country provides adequate protection is sought. This adequacy decision will be given not only for a country in general, but also for a specific sector or international organisation of that country. There is no Adequacy Decision issued by the Authority yet.

In the Guidelines, an example of a Sectoral Qualification Decision is a qualification decision only for the automotive sector of a foreign country with which the Turkish automotive sector trades extensively.

The Board will review the qualification decisions within a period of four years by taking opinions from the relevant institutions and organisations when necessary. If deemed necessary, the qualification decision may be re-evaluated without waiting for the four-year period. If no assessment is made within the 4-year period, the Qualification Decision will remain valid.

Stage 2: What is transfer based on appropriate safeguards?

If the prerequisite is fulfilled but there is no adequacy decision for a country, international organisation or a sector located abroad, and if the relevant persons have the opportunity to exercise their rights and apply for effective legal remedies in the country of transfer, it will be possible to transfer personal data when the “appropriate safeguards” in the Law are provided.

Stage 3: What are the methods for transferring personal data abroad under the scope of exceptional transfer?

It is the case of data transfer that will be considered incidental. Occasionality is stated as personal data transfers that will occur only once or several times and will not be continuous. If there is an occasionality, the permission of the Authority or application to the Authority will not be required.

In the presence of one of the following situations, it will be possible to transfer personal data abroad incidentally;

  • If the person concerned has given explicit consent to the transfer, provided that he/she has been informed about the possible risks, and this explicit consent meets the following conditions due to special risks;
  • If based on information
  • If it is explained by free will
  • If informed about the possible risks
  • If it is related to a specific subject
  • If the transfer is mandatory for the performance of a contract between the data subject and the data controller or for the implementation of pre-contractual measures taken upon the request of the data subject
  • If the transfer is mandatory for the establishment or performance of a contract between the data controller and another natural or legal person for the benefit of the data subject
  • If the transfer is necessary for an overriding public interest
  • If the transfer of personal data is mandatory for the establishment, exercise or protection of a right
  • If the transfer of personal data is mandatory for the protection of the life or physical integrity of the person who is unable to disclose his consent due to actual impossibility or whose consent is not legally valid, or of another person
  • From a register open to the public or persons with a legitimate interest, provided that the conditions required by the relevant legislation to access the register are met and the person with a legitimate interest has requested it

It is possible to transfer personal data abroad.

Who will be responsible for data transfer abroad?

In the case of data transfer abroad, not only the data controller but also the data processor will be obliged to ensure data security if the data transfer abroad is made by the data processor.

Kind regards,

Zumbul Attorneys-At-Law

info@zumbul.av.tr