European Commission Adopts New Horizontal Block Exemption Regulations and Horizontal Guidelines

The European Commission has adopted revised Horizontal Block Exemption Regulations (“HBERs”) and Guidelines on Research and Development (“R&D”) and Specialisation agreements.

These revisions aim to provide clearer and more up-to-date guidance to businesses on how to assess the compatibility of their cooperation agreements with EU competition rules. The new rules will come into effect on July 1, 2023.

The main changes introduced in the revised rules are as follows:

  1. Specialisation Block Exemption Regulation: The scope of this regulation has been expanded to cover a wider range of production agreements involving more than two parties. The calculation of market shares for applying the block exemption has become more flexible, and specific guidance on its application has been provided.
  2. R&D Block Exemption Regulation: The calculation of market shares for applying this regulation has been clarified and made more flexible. The revised rules give more importance to protecting innovation competition, especially when market shares cannot be calculated. The Commission and national competition authorities have been empowered to withdraw the exemption in problematic cases.
  3. Guidelines: The Introductory Chapter of the Guidelines has been updated with the latest case law, addressing concepts such as concerted practices, potential competition, and restrictions by object and by effect. It also provides guidance on agreements between joint ventures and their parent companies, as well as cooperation involving multiple activities.
  4. Mobile Telecommunications Infrastructure Sharing Agreements: A new section in the Guidelines covers this topic, reflecting recent enforcement practices. It outlines relevant assessment factors and lists minimum conditions to reduce the risk of breaching competition rules.
  5. Purchasing Agreements: The Guidelines have been expanded and clarified to reflect recent case practices. The distinction between joint purchasing and buyer cartels has been explained, and it emphasizes potential anti-competitive effects on the upstream supply side. It also provides guidance on joint negotiating tactics.
  6. Commercialisation Agreements: A new section on bidding consortia and bid rigging has been included in the Guidelines.
  7. Information Exchange: The chapter on Information Exchange has been restructured and expanded, considering the latest case law and enforcement experience. It provides additional guidance on commercially sensitive information, types of information exchange that may restrict competition, pro-competitive effects of data pools, and anti-competitive signaling. It also suggests practical measures to avoid infringements.
  8. Standardisation Agreements: The chapter on Standardisation Agreements offers greater flexibility regarding open participation in the standard-setting process. It clarifies that disclosing a maximum cumulated royalty rate is not anti-competitive and outlines the requirement for participants to disclose relevant intellectual property rights.
  9. Sustainability Agreements: A new chapter in the Guidelines clarifies that antitrust rules do not hinder agreements among competitors pursuing sustainability objectives. It defines sustainability objectives based on UN Sustainable Development Goals and provides examples of agreements falling outside the scope of Article 101(1) TFEU. It offers a soft safe harbor for sustainability standardization agreements and describes benefits that may be considered. Hypothetical examples illustrate the application of Article 101 TFEU. Companies can seek informal guidance from the Commission when entering into sustainability agreements.

 

Answers to Questions Regarding New Horizontal Block Exemption Regulations and Acceptance of Horizontal Guidelines

Horizontal cooperation agreements involve collaboration between competitors in various areas such as research and development, production, purchasing, commercialization, standardization, and information exchange. These agreements can lead to economic benefits and help companies adapt to competitive pressures and changing market dynamics. They facilitate risk-sharing, cost savings, increased investments, knowledge pooling, improved product quality, variety, and accelerated innovation. Such cooperation is particularly important for the digital and green transition and contributes to the functioning of the internal market.

Under EU competition law, the new rules for assessing horizontal cooperation agreements include two horizontal Block Exemption Regulations (HBERs) and Horizontal Guidelines. The HBERs exempt certain R&D and specialization agreements from the provisions of Article 101 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union (TFEU). The Horizontal Guidelines provide guidance on applying the HBERs and assessing other types of cooperation agreements, including information exchange, R&D, production, joint purchasing, commercialization, standardization, and standard terms. Additionally, the revised Horizontal Guidelines include a new chapter on assessing sustainability agreements.

When an agreement is "block-exempted," it means that certain agreements between companies with limited market power (combined market shares of 25% or less for R&D agreements and 20% or less for specialization or joint production agreements) and complying with the conditions outlined in the HBERs are presumed to generate positive effects that outweigh any competition restrictions. These agreements are considered compatible with the single market under Article 101(3) TFEU and are exempted from the ban on restrictive agreements stated in Article 101(1) TFEU. If the market shares of companies involved in R&D, specialization, or joint production agreements exceed the specified thresholds, the safe harbor provided by the HBERs does not apply. However, there is no presumption that such agreements are illegal, and each case needs to be individually assessed for potential competition restrictions. The Horizontal Guidelines assist in making this assessment.

The main changes to the R&D BER and the Specialisation BER aim to enhance clarity and usability. They provide clarifications on calculating market share thresholds and offer guidance on applying for the block exemption. For instance, they specify that if sales data for the previous calendar year does not accurately reflect the parties' market position, data from the three preceding years should be used. The grace period, which allows agreements to benefit from the block exemption even after exceeding the market share threshold, has been simplified to two calendar years in all cases.

The R&D BER now addresses the legal consequences of including excluded restrictions in an R&D agreement. It explains that certain restrictions may not fulfill the conditions of Article 101(3) TFEU but their inclusion in the agreement does not nullify the exemption if they can be separated from the rest of the agreement. Additionally, the R&D BER presents conditions related to access to joint R&D results, pre-existing know-how, and joint exploitation of results in separate articles for improved clarity.

The Specialisation BER has been expanded to cover agreements involving more than two parties for all types of specialization and production agreements defined in the HBER. This expansion increases the flexibility of the block exemption.

The revised HBERs prioritize the protection of innovation competition. They highlight that even if the parties to an R&D agreement do not compete in existing product or technology markets, they may still compete in terms of innovation. The regulations include provisions that grant the European Commission and National Competition Authorities (NCAs) the power to withdraw the block exemption if they find that the conditions of Article 101(3) TFEU are not met, particularly if an R&D agreement significantly restricts innovation competition. Similar provisions have been added to the Specialisation BER.

The revised HBERs come into effect on July 1, 2023, and will remain valid for 12 years. There is a transitional period of 2 years during which agreements that do not meet the conditions of the new HBERs but fulfill the conditions of the previous HBERs will still be block-exempted.

The main changes introduced in the Horizontal Guidelines are as follows:

  1. Introduction of a new chapter on sustainability agreements.
  2. Inclusion of a section on mobile telecommunications infrastructure sharing agreements.
  3. Substantial revision of the information exchange chapter.
  4. Expansion of the chapters on R&D and specialization agreements.
  5. Thorough review of the chapters to ensure clarity and ease of application, particularly for small- and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs).
  6. Updated guidance on joint purchasing and commercialization to differentiate legitimate cooperation from illegal buyer cartels and bid rigging.
  7. Coverage of all types of horizontal subcontracting under the chapter on production agreements.
  8. Additional guidance on the notion of preparation of services.
  9. Mobile telecommunications infrastructure sharing agreements are assessed based on their effects on competition and certain factors, such as scope, geographic coverage, and participating operators.
  10. Sustainability agreements refer to horizontal cooperation agreements pursuing sustainability objectives.
  11. Assessment of sustainability agreements focuses on their impact on competition and whether they are used to disguise severe restrictions.
  12. Specific safe harbor for sustainability agreements that set a sustainability standard and meet certain conditions.
  13. Three categories of sustainability benefits considered for Article 101(3) TFEU assessment: individual use value benefits, individual non-use benefits, and collective benefits.
  14. Joint purchasing agreements cover all sectors where buyers team up to jointly purchase goods or services.
  15. Commission assesses joint purchasing agreements considering harm to downstream consumers and upstream competition between suppliers.
  16. Addition of a new section on bidding consortia to provide guidance on joint bids in public procurement procedures.
  17. Thorough rewriting of the chapter on information exchange to address expanding case law and new types of collaboration.
  18. Recognition of both pro-competitive and harmful aspects of data sharing, with guidance on assessing compatibility with EU competition law.
  19. Absence of a safe harbor for information exchanges, but the guidance provided to minimize the risk of competition law infringements.
  20. Transparency and streamlining improvements in the standardization chapter.
  21. Introduction of a new chapter on standard terms and conditions for the sale or purchase of goods or services.
  22. Various changes and references were made in the Horizontal Guidelines to assist SMEs in their self-assessment of horizontal cooperation agreements.
  23. The revised Horizontal Guidelines will apply upon their publication in the Official Journal of the EU, expected in July 2023.

You can reach further information here.

You can reach Q&A here.

Kind regards,

Zumbul Attorneys-at-Law

info@zumbul.av.tr