Duyurular
Court Of Justice Of The European Union: It Has Been Decided That Price Parity Clauses in Online Accommodation Reservation Platforms Cannot Be Classified As Ancillary Restraints Under EU Competition Law
In the press release published on its official website on September 19, 2024 the Court of Justice announced that in principle, price equality provisions cannot be categorised as ‘ancillary restraints’ for the purposes of EU competition law.
According to the press release;
- Booking.com, a company based in Amsterdam (Netherlands) and governed by Dutch law, offers a worldwide online intermediation service for accommodation reservations. Hotel establishments pay a commission to Booking.com for every reservation made through the platform. These establishments are prohibited from offering overnight stay prices lower than those on Booking.com. This prohibition currently only applies to hotels offering lower prices through their own sales channels.
- The German courts, without referring questions to the Court, determined that the price parity clauses (both narrow and wide) used by hotel reservation platforms were contrary to EU competition law. The German Federal Cartel Office had already reached a similar conclusion.
- Hearing an action brought by Booking.com seeking, inter alia, a declaration that the parity clauses employed by that company were valid, the District Court, Amsterdam, decided to refer questions to the Court of Justice for a preliminary ruling concerning the compatibility of price parity clauses, both narrow and wide, in the light of the EU competition rules
- In its judgment, the Court emphasises that the provision of online hotel reservation services by platforms such as Booking.com has had a neutral, or even positive, effect on competition. Those services enable consumers, on the one hand, to have access to a wide range of accommodation offers and to compare those offers simply and quickly according to various criteria and accommodation providers, on the other hand, to acquire greater visibility.
- However, it has not been established that price parity clauses, whether wide or narrow, first, are objectively necessary for the implementation of that main operation and, second, are proportionate to the objective pursued by it.
- Regarding wide parity clauses, it should be noted that they are likely to reduce competition and pose the risk of excluding small platforms and new entrants. The same is true for narrow parity clauses; while they may appear to have a less restrictive effect on competition, they do not seem to be objectively necessary to ensure the economic viability of the hotel reservation platform.
You can reach further information here.
Kind regards,
Zumbul Attorneys-at-Law
Türkçe
English