CJEU Opinion on the Possibility of Claiming Non-Material Damages for Fear of Future Misuse of Personal Data Leaked as a Result of a Data Breach

-Advocate General’s Opinion in Case C-340/21 | Natsionalna agentsia za prihodite  -

The Court of Justice of the European Union ("CJEU") in its assessment of a data breach case originating in Bulgaria (C-340/21) summarized as;

  • Unlawful access to personal data by third parties causes the data controller's liability arising from negligence.
  • Appropriate technical and administrative measures should be taken in case of unlawful access to personal data,.
  • When verifying whether the measures are appropriate, the national court must carry out a review which extends to a specific analysis of the content of those measures and the manner in which they were applied, as well as their practical effects, The need to balance the economic interests and technological capacities of the data subject and the data controller in monitoring the appropriateness of the measures.
  • Furthermore, the onus is on the controller to prove the appropriateness of the measures.
  • In the event that the fear of possible future misuse of personal data subject to a data breach due to a data breach is accepted as non- material damage, it gives the person concerned the right to claim compensation.

You can access the full text of the opinion dated April 27, 2023 and numbered 67/23 here.

Kind regards,

Zumbul Attorneys at Law

info@zumbul.av.tr